I didn’t start thinking about search this way because of SEO.
I started thinking about it this way because too many decisions began slowing down without a clear reason.
The meetings were fine.
The conversations were constructive.
No one said “no”.
And yet, momentum quietly dropped.
Over time, it became clear that the judgement hadn’t begun in the room. It had begun earlier — on search.
One of the earliest times I noticed this pattern was while working with a large retail brand operating across multiple cities.
Internally, the business was confident. Store performance was steady, offline recall was strong, and there was no sense that trust was an issue. Marketing believed the challenge was largely about improving conversion efficiency.
When we reviewed branded search results together, the hesitation made sense.
There was no single damaging result. Instead, there were familiar issues repeating across locations — similar review complaints that had never been visibly closed, older store pages ranking without updates, and marketplace listings carrying more narrative weight than the brand’s own site.
Nothing here would trigger a crisis response.
But taken together, it created doubt.
Not enough to stop someone outright — just enough to slow them down.
This showed up again in a very different context — a B2B services firm where leadership believed search mattered mainly for demand generation.
During a routine walkthrough of their branded results, what stood out wasn’t rankings or traffic. It was behaviour.
Senior stakeholders didn’t scroll far. They didn’t open content assets. What made them pause were small things: leadership names appearing only in older contexts, third-party pages explaining the company more than the company itself, and gaps where reassurance should have existed.
There was no negative press.
There was just uncertainty.
That uncertainty explained why deals were taking longer than expected, even though nothing in the pitch had materially changed.
I’ve seen this most clearly in services-heavy and regulated sectors.
In one engagement, several known issues had already been addressed internally. Processes had been corrected, teams had moved on, and leadership felt the chapter was closed.
Search told a different story.
Older articles still ranked. Review narratives remained unresolved in public view. Forum discussions continued without updated context.
Internally, these were historical issues.
Externally, they still looked current.
That gap — between what the organisation knows and what search shows — is where judgement usually starts forming.
Most organisations don’t think of search as an evaluation surface.
They think of it as:
But in practice, search is where people decide how much caution to apply.
Not whether to engage — but how carefully.
That distinction matters.
I’ve also seen teams try to solve this by increasing visibility.
More campaigns.
More spend.
More content.
In at least one consumer-facing business, this had the opposite effect. Increased visibility drove more branded searches. More people encountered the same unresolved signals. Sales teams reported longer conversations and more defensive questions.
Marketing did its job.
Search perception didn’t change.
Visibility amplified attention. It didn’t resolve hesitation.
When I review search today, I’m not primarily looking at rankings.
I’m looking for:
Often, it’s not one result that causes doubt. It’s two or three results reinforcing the same concern.
That combination is usually enough to shape judgement.
Search environments are becoming more compressed.
AI summaries collapse nuance.
Patterns surface faster.
Context drops away quickly.
That means early impressions harden sooner than they used to.
By the time someone speaks to you, search has often already shaped their expectations, their caution, and their questions.
Search is not where marketing begins.
It’s where evaluation begins — quietly, independently, and without the opportunity to explain.
In many cases, it’s the first boardroom where your organisation is discussed — without you in the room.
That’s not a branding problem.
It’s a judgement problem.
Passionate Digital Marketing consultant connecting startups and SME to their target audiences.
Microsoft Advertising Certified Professional
No Comments on This Post